Law News

Dreyfus drops charges against Bernard Collaery

By | | comments |
The new Albanese Government has finally ended the persecution of Bernard Collaery (image via YouTube)

The Albanese Government has acted quickly to abandon the prosecution of Bernard Collaery, who was charged in relation to the leaking of information about Australia’s alleged spying in Timor-Leste.

Attorney-General Mark Dreyfus said that in taking this decision:

I have had careful regard to our national security interest and the proper administration of justice.


It is my view that the prosecution of Mr Collaery should end.

He said the “decision to discontinue the prosecution was informed by the Government’s commitment to protecting Australia’s national interest, including our national security and Australia’s relationships with our close neighbours.”

Collaery, 77, is a former ACT Attorney-General.

He was the lawyer of the whistleblower known as Witness K, a former ASIS officer.

Witness K received a suspended sentence in 2021 after pleading guilty to conspiring with Collaery to reveal information about the alleged spying.

Collaery was due to face trial in October on charges alleging breaches of the Intelligence Services Act.

The alleged Australian government spying was at the time of 2004 negotiations between the two countries over oil and gas reserves in the Timor Sea. The Australian Secret Intelligence Service – Australia’s foreign spy service – allegedly had listening devices in East Timor’s cabinet room in Dili.

Dreyfus told a news conference on Thursday this was: exceptional case. Governments must protect secrets and our government remains steadfast in our commitment to keep Australians safe by keeping secrets out of the wrong hands.


The long-standing practice of government has been to neither confirm nor deny claims made about intelligence matters and I will strictly adhere to that practice.

He said prosecutions involved:

...a balancing of interests. The balance of interests can change over time and this is such a case.


The consent of a former attorney-general was required to commence the prosecution of Mr Collaery. Having had regard to our national security, our national interest and the administration of justice, today I have determined that the prosecution should end.

The proceedings against Collaery have been surrounded by secrecy, with the former Morrison Government arguing they should be heard largely in private. 

Collaery’s home and office were raided in 2013.

At the time he was representing East Timor in The Hague in its action against Australia.

Independent Member for Clark Andrew Wilkie, welcoming Dreyfus’s action, said:

The fact that Mr Collaery was being prosecuted in the first place was a grave injustice and an outrageous attack on the legal profession, particularly considering he was simply a lawyer doing his job.


The Australian government is the real villain in this case, having made the appalling decision to spy on East Timor which is one of the poorest countries in south-east Asia.


While someone should be answering to a court, it certainly should never have been the ASIS whistle-blower and his lawyer.

Centre Alliance Member for Mayo Rebekha Sharkie said:

“Since I stood on the steps of the Canberra Magistrates Court in September 2018, I have been calling for the prosecution of Bernard Collaery to be abandoned.”

She said the decision: pursue this politically-motivated prosecution is an embarrassment to the rule of law in Australia.


At no point during this wretched affair has there been a clear and persuasive argument for why pursuing this case is in the public interest.

Michelle Grattan is an academic and associate editor and chief political correspondent at The ConversationThis article was originally published by The Conversation under the title 'Dreyfus ends prosecution of lawyer over alleged leaking about Australian spying against Timor-Leste'.

Related Articles

Support independent journalism Subscribe to IA.

Recent articles by The Conversation
La Niña could become the norm for Australia

Climate change is slowing down the conveyor belt of ocean currents that brings ...  
Big data: How we are being watched — all the time

Surveillance expert Ausma Bernot explains the many ways in which we are consta ...  
Reforming sexual consent laws faces formidable challenges

With sexual consent laws differing among states, a current push to harmonise these ...  
Join the conversation
comments powered by Disqus

Support IAIndependent Australia

Subscribe to IA and investigate Australia today.

Close Subscribe Donate