Politics Analysis

Coalition to cut NDIS from non-citizens

By | | comments |
The Coalition's proposed NDIS restrictions could leave vulnerable non-citizens without vital disability support (Screenshots via YouTube - edited)

The Coalition’s plan to exclude non-citizens from the NDIS is unlikely to deliver substantial savings and could leave vulnerable migrants and refugees without vital support, writes Dr Abul Rizvi.

AFTER MEDIA REPORTS (and much shock jock outrage) that National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) payments to non-citizens would amount to $53 billion over the next decade, the Coalition has announced it would confine the NDIS to citizens only.

The reporting tried to suggest this would save $53 billion. That is not true.

The media reports say that NDIS expenditure for non-citizens in the 2027 financial year would be $4.6 billion, rising to $5 billion in the early 2030s. 

Not all of that expenditure would be saved for three reasons.

First, it is not clear if that costing is before or after the Labor Government’s proposed changes to the NDIS.

Second, the Coalition says it would grandfather all existing NDIS payments. So the savings would relate only to new entrants to the NDIS.

Third, there would be essentially five groups that may become potential new entrants to the scheme who are not citizens but who would press for the policy to be modified further. 

The first group would be pre-1986 permanent residents who were “grandfathered” because they were British Subjects (this cohort retains most of the rights of citizenship, including the right to vote).

While under Coalition policy all such people currently on the NDIS would remain on the NDIS, any pre-1986 British Subject who is under age 65 (most likely arrived in Australia as a child or young adult and has not taken out citizenship) who becomes disabled after the new policy is introduced would no longer be eligible.

It would be extraordinarily difficult for the Coalition to deny a long-term voter access to a government program that most Australians have access to.

The second group would be disabled partners of Australian citizens who arrive in Australia after the new policy is introduced. These people would have received a visa on the basis of a health waiver. Coalition policy is effectively warning Australian citizens not to marry foreigners with a disability. Once again, a very difficult policy to sustain.

The third group would be new Humanitarian Program entrants (both offshore and onshore) who also receive a health waiver. These tend to be unaccompanied minors or refugee children. Essentially, the Coalition is saying to Department of Home Affairs decision-makers not to use the health waiver for Humanitarian Program entrants no matter how dire their situation in a refugee camp or elsewhere.

Denying a disabled refugee child in Australia access to the NDIS would also be difficult to sustain.

The fourth group would be eligible New Zealand citizens. Australia offers eligible New Zealand citizens access to NDIS services in the same way New Zealand offers Australian citizens who move to New Zealand access to similar services in New Zealand. A new Coalition Government would need to negotiate the proposed arrangements with the New Zealand Government.

Finally, there would be other permanent residents (such as skill stream migrants) who become disabled after arrival (for example, a car accident or they have a child who is disabled) but have not taken out citizenship for whatever reason.

All of these situations are prime targets for media stories about a heartless government. It would not take long before the Coalition started to retreat on its recently announced and rushed policy reacting to a story in the Murdoch press and the usual shock jocks. The savings would quickly dry up, but prior to the next election, the Coalition could continue to say it had again outdone Pauline Hanson on how nasty it could be to migrants.  

 Perhaps it’s just an election strategy.

Dr Abul Rizvi is an Independent Australia columnist and former Deputy Secretary of the Department of Immigration. You can follow Abul on Twitter @RizviAbul or Bluesky @abulrizvi.bsky.social.

Support independent journalism Subscribe to IA.

Related Articles

 
Recent articles by Abul Rizvi
Coalition to cut NDIS from non-citizens

The Coalition’s plan to exclude non-citizens from the NDIS is unlikely to deliver ...  
Asylum seeker backlog slowly reducing but more needs to be done

The asylum seeker backlog Labor inherited after Dutton and Pezzullo lost control of ...  
Australia's immigration debate is being driven by fear, not facts

Political failures, misinformation and poor leadership have fuelled anti-immigra ...  
Join the conversation
comments powered by Disqus

Support Fearless Journalism

If you got something from this article, please consider making a one-off donation to support fearless journalism.

Single Donation

$