Barbarians at the gate: Don’t let them destroy Murray Valley National Park

By | | comments |
(Image by Lucky General 12/07/2019)

John Barilaro intends removing statutory protections of the 42,000 hectare Murray Valley National Park to allow logging, writes Laurie Patton

THE NEW SOUTH WALES deputy premier wants to allow logging in a national park in the state’s RiverinaJohn Barilaro says he intends removing statutory protection of the 42,000 hectare Murray Valley National Park — either by de-gazetting the entire area or reducing its size.

Forty years ago we fought to stop the logging of a rainforest at Terania Creek in northern NSW. I cannot believe this issue is back on the political agenda.

When former NSW premier Neville Wran retired from politics, he was asked at a news conference what was his greatest achievement. His immediate response was “saving the rainforests”.

Back then, the National Party was gung-ho in support of runnning the bulldozers over just about any tree found standing. In what was a low point for the Labor Party, some of its more rightwing MPs also supported wholesale logging. To be fair, this was not so much about any disregard for the importance of our rainforests as it was a keenness to protect the jobs of timber workers.

Wran’s eventual Labor successor, Bob Carr, holds the mantle of the state’s premier who gazetted the most national parks. Bob Debus, as Carr’s environment minister, also justifiably lays claim to having played a key role in saving our rainforest heritage.

But it was Wran’s Attorney General, the late Frank Walker, who should be given credit for achieving one of the first big breakthroughs in the protection of our natural environment. Saving Terania Creek set the scene for the next two decades of progress. As a small disclosure, I was Walker’s speechwriter and policy advisor at the time.

While various people and organisations have rightly claimed their share of the credit for saving the Terania Creek forest, the untold "back story" is worthy of recognition. Nothing that I have read about others’ actions is in dispute — I’m just adding an important component to the history.

While Walker had no direct responsibility for environmental matters, he was a committed and well-known greenie. It was for this reason that the situation at Terania Creek was brought to his attention well before many others in the Wran Government became aware of it.

noted interventionist across other portfolios, Walker’s response to hearing about Terania Creek was to dispatch me and a colleague to undertake an informal inspection, where we met with local activists. On returning to Sydney, our advice was that the forest should be saved. But more important in the telling of the full story and what really happened, we said that in our view the determination and resolve of a band of recent arrivals in the area – young professionals, the first "tree changers" – was such that they could be expected to create serious grief for the Government.

Walker immediately reported our observations to Wran and subsequently convinced him to act. As I said earlier, nothing I have read elsewhere is in conflict with what I am recounting now. Wran then set about instigating processes that led to more official visits to the area and formal investigations.

As the media reported at the time, Terania Creek

'...was the first time citizens physically defended a rainforest by placing themselves in front of police and loggers.'

Another small disclosure. Walker’s staff might not have discouraged the protestors from taking that action. It was relatively short-lived, but it certainly gave Wran the political cover he needed to prevail over his combatant MPs.

Understandably concerned about the future employment prospects for timber workers, a small but powerful lobby within the Labor Party fought hard against our plan to ban logging at Terania Creek. It was Walker’s persistence and his success in convincing Wran that was the crucial determinant. This was assisted by compensation, including a retraining scheme and a redundancy package for displaced workers. A model that should be repeated more often when change affects jobs.

Walker’s actions behind the scenes should now be publicly recognised. Under immense pressure from some of his caucus members, who in turn were being lobbied by the timber workers union, Wran certainly needed some persuading. So it was really Frank Walker who saved Terania Creek.

Four decades later, it looks like we’ll have to go through it all again. Can you believe it?


The Australian Labor Party has changed significantly since the Wran era. One of its wiliest members to occupy a positon of power on behalf of the dominant NSW rightwing, Graham Richardson, went on to serve as Environment Minister in the Hawke Government.

Laurie Patton was an advisor in the Wran Government from 1977 to 1982. This article was originally published on The Lucky General and has been republished with permission.

Support independent journalism Subscribe to IA.

Recent articles by Laurie Patton
Space is a junkyard but we still have no quality broadband

Companies such as Starlink are cluttering space with inferior satellites with ...  
Labor could be key to a better relationship with China

A change in government could be instrumental in repairing the damaged relationship ...  
Van Onselen and the decline of journalism

A rise in media bias has resulted in a decline in journalistic integrity and ...  
Join the conversation
comments powered by Disqus

Support IAIndependent Australia

Subscribe to IA and investigate Australia today.

Close Subscribe Donate