Like Trump, Turnbull's environmental WTFness is propelling us to disaster

By | | comments |
Turnbull's latest brainsnap is to use taxpayer funded Clean Energy Finance Corporation to fund "clean coal" (because no-one else will!). Image via @climatecouncil)

Like many Americans, Australians are wondering how the hell we ended up with a PM whose environment policies are a recipe for disaster. Sue Arnold reports.

AS THE Trump horror reality show unfolds, a collective shudder is being felt around the world. His anti-environmental policies are winding back half a century of progressive laws created to ensure healthy human and animal habitats for current and future generations.

With the U. S. Environment Protection Agency now in the hands of climate sceptic and resource industry front man Scott Pruitt, the Agency is scheduled to be repealed in 2018. The Endangered Species Act is also on the hit list and a U.S. withdrawal from the Paris Agreement is definitely on the cards.

At the same time, scientists have announced that the ocean oxygen levels have dropped by 2% in 50 years — a truly frightening scenario. According to the WWF Report 2015, populations of marine vertebrates have declined by up to 50% since 1970. Coral reefs are predicted to be extinct by 2050.

The Great Barrier Reef (Image courtesy australiansforanimals.org.au)

According to Dr Richard Leakey, author of The Sixth Extinction, within the next 30 years, half of the species on earth could die in one of the fastest mass extinctions in the planet’s 4.5 billion years of history.

Yet the legacy of future generations has no currency with the world’s most powerful leader.

Banging the drum for “clean coal” and “putting the miners back to work”, Trump is ensuring pollution of rivers, forests, air, water and the agricultural lands on which we depend for the very stuff of life. His refusal to acknowledge the damage climate change is wreaking on the planet is a threat to human existence.

Dirty, polluting coal (Image courtesy australiansforanimals.org.au)

A similar scene is unfolding in Australia as Malcolm Turnbull leads the way with a similar mindless rejection of environmental reality. Witness his latest Trump style policy to use the Clean Energy Finance Corporation to fund “clean coal”. Utter madness.

Where does this arrogance originate?

I remember when I first clapped eyes on the prime minister. It was in Anchorage, Alaska at an International Whaling Commission meeting in 2007. I was walking down the street to the motel where I was staying, after suffering through a rigorous session on Japanese whaling. Turnbull, then Australia’s environment minister, was heading up the sidewalk towards the IWC meeting.

Never having seen the guy before, I was struck by his attitude. He walked like a man who believed he was God. An aura of importance oozing from every pore. Head held high, body language warning the peasants to make way. Just like Trump.

It’s almost impossible to separate Turnbull and Trump in terms of their attitudes towards the environment. The record speaks for itself. Given the current PM’s repeated assertions he’s an environmentalist, his sell-out on climate change, and his obvious deference to the extreme right wing of the Liberal Party, perhaps it’s time to change the definition of environmentalism. With “clean coal” now his government’s mantra, the PM is better described as a hypocrite, blind to the appalling state of this country’s environment.

Look at the record ...

The most recent State of the Environment Report is dated 2011.

Key findings include:

  • Biodiversity has declined since European settlement.
  • Most pressures on biodiversity that arise directly or indirectly from human activities appear to still be strong.
  • Despite promising investment by all jurisdictions in addressing the main pressures on biodiversity, pressures are not being substantially reduced, nor is the decline in biodiversity being arrested or reversed.
  • The major future drivers of change – climate change, population growth, economic development and associated consumption of natural resources – must be managed carefully if a sustainable relationship between biodiversity and human societies is to be achieved.
  • Data on long-term trends in biodiversity are limited, making it difficult to interpret the state or trends of major animal and plant groups in most jurisdictions.
  • Australia can improve its biodiversity management significantly.

Australians cannot afford to see themselves as separate from biodiversity.

Professor Ian Lowe, Griffith University summed up more problems including:

  • worsening traffic snarls in poorly connected, sprawling cities;
  • population pressures along our much-loved coastline;
  • degradation of productive rural land;
  • major declines in native wildlife;
  • the growing global challenge of rising greenhouse gas emissions; and
  • major gaps in our knowledge and monitoring across many areas. As any management expert will tell you, you can’t properly manage what you don’t measure.

Australia’s endemic mammal extinctions comprise 35 per cent of the world’s modern mammal extinctions according to Professor Woinarski and colleagues in a paper published in April 2015.

The koala has been nominated by the International Union for the Conservation of Nature as one of ten most vulnerable species to climate change.

Koalas are now a threatened species. (Image courtesy australiansforanimals.org.au)

Australia's native forests are under threat from rising temperatures, drought, and disease. Their contribution to storing carbon has been ignored as exponential logging continues.

The Great Barrier Reef World Heritage Area is in a parlous state with massive coral die-off which will be exacerbated with exponentially increasing shipping traffic, infrastructure and the looming Adani Carmichael mine operation. Adani mine annual carbon emissions were calculated by The Australia Institute to emit double the amount of emissions by Tokyo, three times the average annual emissions of New Delhi, six times that of Amsterdam and nearly half the average annual emissions of Beijing.

Several bills languishing in the parliament demonstrate the future of Australia’s unique environmental legacy under a Coalition Government, highlighting the move towards Trump extinction policies.

The Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Amendment (Standing) Bill 2015 aims to remove extended standing for community members (including environment groups) to seek judicial review of decisions made under the EPBC Act. Standing would then be restricted to a person 'whose interests are adversely affected by the decision'. If this bill is passed by the Senate, the onus of protecting specific environmental matters would be in the hands of individuals who could demonstrate their “interests are adversely affected by the decision". Common law has interpreted this to require “special interest”.

The likelihood of individuals mounting lawsuits against the Federal Government is remote.

Also languishing is the Environment Protection & Biodiversity Conservation Amendment ( Bilateral Agreement Implementation) Bill 2014which would slash the number of projects the Commonwealth is required to oversee for approval by delegating national environmental powers to the states and territories. The bill has already passed the House of Representatives.

If and when these bills pass the Senate, Australians will be sharing a similar situation to the U.S. with lack of legislation, lack of access to the courts, lack of standing and a complete inability to protect the environment.

Thus far, Turnbull has not had to adopt Trump style attacks on the media as the Murdoch press continues its unprecedented propaganda efforts to support “clean coal”. Murdoch publications continue their unrelenting and unsubstantiated attacks on renewable energy, environmentalists, scientists and public interest organisations concerned by climate change impacts.

Like many Americans, Australians are not only fed up with the major political parties and their lust for power, but most of us are wondering how the hell we ended up with a PM whose policies are recipes for disaster in this time of environmental crises.

You can follow Sue Arnold on Twitter @koalacrisis and Koala Crisis on Facebook here.

Creative Commons Licence
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Australia License

Monthly Donation


Single Donation


It's a good environment. Subscribe to IA for just $5.

Recent articles by Sue Arnold
Housing woes to worsen with upsurge in migration

With housing rents rising and construction times on new homes blown out to over a ...  
How NASA and the CIA championed an unlikely scientific study

Russell Targ, American physicist, parapsychologist and author of nine books dealing ...  
The Trump presidency has brought on the self-destruction of Western civilisation: FLASHBACK 2020

Former U.S. President Donald Trump is about to become the first president to face ...  
Join the conversation
comments powered by Disqus

Support IAIndependent Australia

Subscribe to IA and investigate Australia today.

Close Subscribe Donate