Technology Analysis

'Naked' internet needs digital clothing, shelter and manners

By | | comments |
Under MyTerms, individuals could present their own standardised, machine-readable privacy conditions when visiting a website (Antoni Shkraba | Pexels)

Digital platforms should accept responsibility for the online environments they create, but internet users also need tools that allow them to exercise control on their end, writes Paul Budde. 

IN MY RECENT article on Australia’s proposed Digital Duty of Care, I argued that digital platforms should accept responsibility for the environments they create.

Legislation can impose obligations from above. But internet users also need tools that allow them to exercise control from below.

My American colleague Doc Searls describes the underlying problem memorably: on the internet, we are naked.

In the natural world, people addressed privacy through clothing, shelter and social protocols such as manners. The internet has not developed effective equivalents. We visit websites through browsers and frequently leave covered in invisible tracking beacons.

To the advertising technology industry, personal privacy has too often been treated as a defect rather than a desirable feature. Tracking has become normal, while privacy regulation attempts to control the resulting excesses.

As chair of an Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) working group, Doc helped create IEEE 7012-2025, the Standard for Machine-Readable Personal Privacy Terms, published in January 2026.

It is known as MyTerms, just as IEEE 802.11 is better known as Wi-Fi.

People bring their own terms

MyTerms, as Doc describes on his blog, reverses the relationship that has dominated the digital economy.

Companies currently write privacy policies and conditions that users must accept if they want access. Cookie banners create an appearance of choice, but people are routinely pushed towards accepting tracking.

Under MyTerms, individuals could present their own standardised, machine-readable privacy conditions when visiting a website or using an online service.

The individual becomes the first party and the company the second. A browser, application or personal digital agent could present the person’s chosen terms automatically. They could, for example, be chosen from a list of standard terms. The organisation could accept them, reject them or propose an alternative. Both sides would retain a record of any resulting agreement, backed by contract law.

This differs from clicking a consent box or sending a “Do Not Track” request that a company can ignore. Under MyTerms, the individual proposes conditions that can become a contractual agreement.

An argument dating back to 2001

The MyTerms principle resembles the permission-based model I began advocating more than 25 years ago.

In a 2001 submission to the Productivity Commission, I argued that emerging broadband services needed business models based on permission-based marketing.

People should control their personal information and decide whether, and under what conditions, businesses could use it. Advertising could continue, but it should be based on informed participation rather than hidden data extraction.

I repeated this argument in subsequent BuddeComm reports on broadband, mobile services, digital media and privacy. By 2008, our research included sections titled 'People need to be in charge' and 'Industry control needs to be changed into trust'.

Unfortunately, permission-based systems lost out to surveillance advertising. Personal data became a valuable commercial asset, while control shifted from individual people to platforms and algorithms.

MyTerms provides a technical framework for returning to the original principle.

Advertising without surveillance

MyTerms separates advertising from behavioural surveillance.

A person could allow a website to display advertisements while refusing permission to be tracked across other sites or incorporated into a behavioural profile. In simple terms: show me advertisements, but do not follow me around the internet.

Advertising existed long before surveillance platforms. Contextual advertising related to the material being viewed does not require companies to construct detailed profiles of individual people.

MyTerms could also support transparent exchanges in which people provide specified information in return for a better service, lower price or relevant offers. The difference is that the exchange would be understood, voluntary and recorded.

Working with the duty of care

Doc stresses that MyTerms is not about creating regulation. He compares its potential development with the way TCP/IP and HTTP became accepted internet standards because they provided common ways for networks to communicate.

MyTerms seeks to create a similar common layer for personal agency.

This complements Australia’s Digital Duty of Care. The duty would impose minimum safety responsibilities on platforms. MyTerms would allow individuals to state additional requirements covering tracking, data sharing, targeted advertising, AI training and perhaps algorithmic recommendations.

However, MyTerms cannot replace regulation. Individuals do not negotiate with global platforms from positions of equal power. Children and vulnerable people cannot be expected to manage contractual relationships with social-media companies.

Nor can individual privacy agreements address every societal effect of addictive design, algorithmic amplification and disinformation.

The duty of care must establish the minimum standard below which platforms cannot go. MyTerms could then give individuals meaningful control above that minimum.

Its success will depend on adoption by browsers, personal AI agents, operating systems, websites and platforms. Governments could assist by recognising MyTerms agreements under privacy and consumer law without taking control of the standard.

The internet needs more than regulation. It also needs the digital equivalents of clothing, shelter and manners.

The Digital Duty of Care seeks to make platforms responsible for their systems. MyTerms seeks to give people the means to enter those systems with privacy, dignity and agency.

Paul Budde is an IA columnist and managing director of independent telecommunications research and consultancy, Paul Budde Consulting. You can follow Paul on Twitter @PaulBudde.

Support independent journalism Subscribe to IA.

 
Recent articles by Paul Budde
'Naked' internet needs digital clothing, shelter and manners

Internet users need the tools to exercise control over their digital privacy to ...  
Australians are losing control of their digital lives – and democracy is paying the price

Consumers are becoming more selective about digital spending, increasingly scept ...  
New plan needed to deliver 6G technological and revenue benefits

6G may deliver another technological revolution, but it may not deliver much ...  
Join the conversation
comments powered by Disqus

Support Fearless Journalism

If you got something from this article, please consider making a one-off donation to support fearless journalism.

Single Donation

$