Politics Analysis

Victorians face serious risk of more destructive asset sell-offs

By | | comments |
Victoria faces the prospect of further public asset sell-offs, raising fears of a repeat of the costly privatisations of the Kennett era (Background and map via Magnific, sign via iStock)

Flogging off Victoria’s remarkably efficient electricity system was a spectacularly stupid mistake, as Alan Austin recalls.

FOR MANY DECADES, the good people of Brunswick, Coburg and Northcote in Melbourne’s inner North received their electricity supply via substations owned and operated by their local councils.

Residents and councillors in these low-income communities expected costs to be covered by the quarterly bills, but no profits skimmed. Any excess margin went back to the community.

Most of Melbourne’s councils that provided this service thus ensured power invoices were seldom onerous. In cases of hardship, payment was deferred or waived altogether.

That has changed dramatically. Power is still distributed to Melbourne’s inner north by government agencies. But struggling residents can no longer discuss their plight with local members of the governments seeking payment. Now, those governments are in Beijing and Singapore.

Power is distributed to Melbourne’s inner north by Jemena Electricity Networks, 60% owned by China's State Grid Corporation and 40% by the Singapore Government’s SP Group.
Part of Brunswick and all of Melbourne’s CBD and inner east get their electricity from Citipower, which is 51% owned by a Hong Kong-based corporation and 49% by North Americans.

Both are highly profitable. Jemena’s 2025 operating profit was $728.5 million, up from $682.6 million in 2024. Citipower’s holding company reported $683.3 million in gross profit last year, up from $602.7 million in 2024.

Many of the competing retail marketing companies are also foreign-owned, including EnergyAustralia, Alinta, Powershop and Kogan Energy.

Tragic destruction of a successful system

Victorians made a disastrous blunder in 1992, and they and their children are paying dearly for it today. Their grandchildren and later descendants will suffer further disadvantage indefinitely.

After Victorians elected the assertive and abrasive Jeff Kennett as Premier in October 1992, he set about selling off community-owned services to private companies.

By 1995 he had broken up the State Electricity Commission (SEC) into component parts – generation, transmission, distribution and retail – and sold them to companies either fully or partly foreign-owned, mostly U.S.-based.

Several of those buyers failed to make a profit and offloaded them to other operators, some of which had no sense of service to Victorian consumers. Most have now ended up controlled by remote Asian governments, as have the three remaining brown coal power stations at Loy Yang and Yallourn.

While Kennett promised strict price controls at the outset – and actually reduced some tariffs in the 1990s – prices have soared since.

Electricity inflation today

Tragically, some other states shared Kennett’s enthusiasm, extending the disaster beyond Victoria.

From September 2024 to September 2026, the average price of electricity across Australia increased 50.5%. That’s six times the inflation over that period for the full basket of goods and services the Bureau of Statistics (ABS) measures, which was 8.1%.

This follows a surge of 11% per year in retail electricity prices from 2007 to 2012. No other costs have exploded like this. The only other items to have risen more than 16% over the last two years are petrol (up 27.1%) and tobacco (up 23%).

Consequences for households and the economy

The damage cannot be overestimated. The former community-owned monopoly served Victoria extremely well. Abundant power was available most years for homes, offices, paper mills, steelworks, aluminium smelters, Melbourne’s trams and the statewide train system.

Cheap power from efficient open-cut brown coal mines largely protected Australia from the global oil price shocks of 1973 and 1979.

A 1994 study by the Bureau of Industry Economics found the SEC’s electricity prices were eighth-lowest among 40 advanced nations.

In 1993, the final year before the SEC was broken up, it yielded a profit of $207 million and paid a dividend to Victorians of $191 million plus another $995 million in interest.

As virtually all Australian businesses use electricity, they must now send part of their earnings offshore. This reduces profitability across the entire economy.

Low-income households have found the price hikes particularly difficult. They have contributed significantly to pockets of persistent poverty.

Imagine if electricity prices had not surged 50% in the last two years and even more prior to that. Where would inflation and interest rates be now? Quite likely hitting the Reserve Bank’s target.

An academic study by Dr John Quiggin found Australia’s electricity privatisation has been ‘a spectacular failure’.

Risk of similar disasters

Victorians next Saturday should not elect any candidate who hasn’t committed in writing – preferably in blood – never to sell off public assets again.

Just as Jeff Kennett used the modest state debt left by the preceding Kirner Government as an excuse to flog off public assets, there is a risk Kennett’s acolyte Jess Wilson will privatise Victoria’s hospitals, V/Line trains, Melbourne Water and other valuable publicly-owned properties.

Wilson has already agreed to sell off the Melbourne Wholesale Fruit and Vegetable Market and substantial public land. This should be warning enough.

Five encouraging developments

Is buying back the whole electricity system viable? Only if all major parties collaborate nationwide, because networks in Victoria, New South Wales, South Australia, Queensland and Tasmania are now integrated into the National Electricity Market (NEM).

But there are signs of hope.

Firstly, millions of Australian households and businesses now operate their own small-scale solar and other generators.

Second, commercial solar and wind farms and hydro-electric projects are steadily becoming more efficient, particularly in Victoria.

Third, Victoria’s Labor Government revived the State Electricity Commission in 2022 to restore some of the advantages squandered by earlier Coalition folly. Its focus is on renewables.

Fourth, Victoria’s generally sound management has resulted in the lowest average wholesale electricity prices and hence the best prices to consumers. Then come Tasmania, Queensland, Western Australia, NSW and South Australia.

Finally, encouragingly, a review panel appointed by the Albanese Government is exploring all options for the nation.

Victoria’s future, however, will largely depend on whether voters next Saturday avoid another costly blunder.

Alan Austin is an Independent Australia columnist and freelance journalist. You can follow him on Twitter @alanaustin001 and Bluesky @alanaustin.bsky.social.

Support independent journalism Subscribe to IA.

Related Articles

 
Recent articles by Alan Austin
Victorians face serious risk of more destructive asset sell-offs

Flogging off Victoria’s remarkably efficient electricity system was a spectacu ...  
Victoria still leads the nation despite frenzied pre-election falsehoods

With elections looming in Victoria and NSW, Alan Austin compares all Australian ...  
Newsrooms sook at substantial national reform and global successes

As evidence of economic progress piles up, the anti-Labor reporters redouble ...  
Join the conversation
comments powered by Disqus

Support Fearless Journalism

If you got something from this article, please consider making a one-off donation to support fearless journalism.

Single Donation

$