Frydenberg: Demoting science, ignoring data but singing own praises on climate

By | | comments |

Josh Frydenberg protests that the Turnbull Government is on track to achieve climate goals. Unfortunately, that’s not the same as cutting emissions. Peter Boyer reports.

IF YOU'RE FEELING RELIEVED that the average temperature in 2017 around the world and in Australia was slightly lower than that of the record-breaking year of 2016, stop right now.

There is nothing in the latest temperature data to feel good about.

While 2016 experienced an El Niño weather event, which tends to push global temperatures markedly higher, 2017 didn’t.

Even so, the European Union’s climate-monitoring service, Copernicus, says that last year was still warmer than 2015 and 2014, and all other years on the record, going back to the mid-1800s. It was also half a degree warmer than the 1981-2010 average and 1.2oC warmer than in the 1700s.

Annual average global surface temperatures over the past 40 years, derived from NASA and Copernicus data. (Source: South Wind)

The Bureau of Meteorology (BOM) announced last month that the world was in a weak La Niña phase, which may help ensure 2018 remains below 2016. But that’s little comfort.

In Australia, the Bureau said last week, 2017 continued the trend of warmer-than-average years, coming in third hottest behind 2016 and 2015, both of which had been affected by a strong El Niño.

Nobody could be surprised by any of this. Science revealed 150 years ago that carbon dioxide retains heat energy. It’s 70 years since we knew that carbon dioxide levels in the air were rising and strong evidence that this was causing global warming surfaced in the 1980s.

In the 25 years since nations resolved to act, in 1992, the level of atmospheric carbon dioxide has continued to climb ever more rapidly. It is now well clear of 400 parts per million everywhere in the world — 45 per cent higher than in pre-industrial times.

Some nations, notably European ones, are performing better than others, but China still depends heavily on coal to power its growth, and Donald Trump and the U.S. Congress continue to behave as if nothing is happening. Small successes are being dwarfed by monumental failure.

All nations are culpable, but as the only nation to ditch carbon pricing, Australia is especially so. We replaced a promising but deficient pricing scheme (it didn’t tackle transport) with a mish-mash of ineffectual measures that skirt around the central problem: fossil-fuel emissions.

In the Hobart Mercury on 2 January, Minister for the Environment Josh Frydenberg took issue with my negative comments in December about his Government’s performance on climate, writing that I overlooked “significant action”.

He wrote that the Government would “easily surpass” its 2020 emission target and had a much better “emissions outlook” than when Labor was in power. He said the Clean Energy Finance Corporation and the Australian Renewable Energy Agency had lowered the cost of innovation.

While both those agencies are doing well, there’s a whiff of hypocrisy in underpinning an argument with such Labor initiatives without mentioning that his own Government sought to abolish them. And surpassing modest targets using highly-uncertain land-use data is nothing to be proud of.

Frydenberg said I had belittled and “ridiculed” key measures of his Government. I admit to angry words, but my message was that the scheme's emissions-cutting capacity was overblown. Ignoring transport emissions, for instance, is surely a shortcoming as it was under Labor’s carbon price.

The failure of existing measures to bring down fossil-fuel emissions is on clear display in the Government’s own data. The passage of time means new measures need be tougher than what previously applied. My complaint is that they’re actually weaker.

Frydenberg referred to my 'latest polemic against the Turnbull Government'. This says a lot about the parlous state of climate policy in the Government. Branding criticism as a "polemic" apparently gives licence to ignore the substance of the criticism, which gets us nowhere.

This should not be so personal. The PM and his Environment Minister may mean well, but they have fallen captive to a minority sentiment in their party that sees global warming as nothing more than politics — a leftist plot. Such a sentiment precludes rational discussion of climate issues.

It’s a disease that has persisted here and elsewhere in the developed world, led by perhaps the most ideologically-driven, least informed President ever to sit in the Oval Office.

With gung ho U.S. Environmental Protection Agency head Scott Pruitt and Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke as his attack dogs, Donald Trump has presided over the systematic dismantling of previous administrations’ climate measures, while also sacking or silencing government scientists.

So far, successive Coalition governments have not rejected wholesale the advice of professional scientists and other specialists — although Tony Abbott as PM dipped a toe in this murky water.

In light of its repeated failure to respond to scientists’ pleas to put teeth into climate measures – not to mention Turnbull’s demotion of science to a non-cabinet portfolio during the Christmas rush (funny, that) – it’s reasonable to conclude that the Government is putting ideology ahead of reality.

The world has wasted precious time playing politics with climate change. Now we are reaping the miserable consequences.

This article was originally published in South Wind and is reproduced with permission. You can follow Peter Boyer on Twitter @PeterBoyer8.

Monthly Donation


Single Donation


Make a change. Subscribe to IA.

Recent articles by Peter Boyer
Frydenberg: Demoting science, ignoring data but singing own praises on climate

Josh Frydenberg protests that the Turnbull Government is on track to achieve ...  
Turnbull Government conceals damning climate data

The Turnbull Government is negligently concealing its massive climate change policy ...  
Barnaby shows Coalition's apathy to Murray-Darling water theft

Barnaby Joyce's boasts about Murray-Darling water theft epitomise the Turnbull ...  
Join the conversation
comments powered by Disqus

Support Fearless Journalism

If you got something from this article, please consider making a one-off donation to support fearless journalism.

Single Donation


Support IAIndependent Australia

Subscribe to IA and investigate Australia today.

Close Subscribe Donate