Gold Coast Mayor Tom Tate says he accepts bottles of Penfolds Grange because it is “polite”. Managing editor David Donovan continues his investigation.
[READ PART ONE: 'The strange case of the developer mayor, the kid's charity and the bottle of Grange']
THE GOLD COAST mayoral debate held on Monday 7 March was about 40 minutes in when a middle-aged man towards the back was handed the microphone.
“NSW Premier Barry O’Farrell lost his job over being given a bottle of Penfolds Grange Hermitage. What would each of the candidates do if they were offered a bottle of this very expensive wine?”
Tittering was heard around the packed Tugun Progress Association Hall.
Up on the podium, round-faced Mayor Tom Tate responded in his croaky, strangulated voice:
“Well, I used to be a publican, so I have a few bottles of Grange tucked around the place."
Mayor Tate arrives at the Tugun Community Hall for the mayoral debate (7 March 2016), to join already seated candidates Jim Wilson and Penny Toland (Image: author)
“But it’s polite to accept a gift, so I’d take it.”
The crowd laughed. Of course he would. After all, he’s done it before.
Indeed, according to a report in the Courier-Mail, as well as being Queensland’s richest mayor, Tom Tate is also the most “polite”, having politely accepted more gifts than any other local government leader in the State.
Glancing around at the chuckling crowd, Tate continued:
“And then I’d look to find a way to auction it off for the benefit of some worthy charity.”
Well, perhaps he would.
Gold Coast Mayor Tom Tate enjoys more perks of office than most of his colleagues https://t.co/hFF1OyMvRy— Dave Donovan (@davrosz) March 12, 2016
But still, a couple of things jar about Mayor Tate’s response.
Firstly, as the recent IA investigation showed, when Tate was given a $750 bottle of Penfolds Grange 2010 last year at the Starlight Foundation’s Star Ball on the Gold Coast by Starlight Committee member and corporate boss Peter Greelish, he didn’t donate it straight back to the charity. No, Tate instead took the gift home to “tuck around” his multi-million dollar mansion.
So, is Tate saying the Starlight Foundation is not a “worthy charity”? Did he auction it afterwards or donate it to some other? Unfortunately, the question was never asked as the microphone moved to some other Tugun local.
Tom Tate: The "polite" mayor?
The whole notion of this Gold Coast mayor prioritising politeness seems rather a radical claim. The developer mayor may be known for many things, but courtesy just isn’t one of them.
For instance, in an expletive strewn Gold Coast Bulletin weekend puff piece published just prior to the debate ‒ one accompanied by disturbing pictures of the short rolly polly pollie “pumping iron” in a gym ‒ Mayor Tate was asked why he should be re-elected:
“You want a safe pair of hands, a willing pair of hands, hands prepared to have a go … not these fuckers who just bring up bullshit.”
Mayor Tate's politeness does not appear to extend to opposing candidates (Image scan of Gold Coast Bulletin, 5 March 2016)
The “fuckers”, presumably the five other mayoral candidates, were all there on Monday night and some of them took great exception with Mayor Polite.
Mayoral candidate Jim Wilson, a local solicitor and businessperson, had dozens of his supporters inside and outside the venue. He was clearly less than enthusiastic about Tom Tate’s unsolicited character appraisal.
In his opening address to the Tugun debate, Candidate Wilson went straight onto the attack:
“Mayor Tate wants to bring business to the Gold Coast, but then we see quotes about other mayoral candidates being ‘fuckers’.
Wilson continued [IA emphasis]:
“Do you think being a weight pumping bikie bovver boy on steroids is likely to attract business to the City?”
Perhaps not if the details in a Frank Robson Sydney Morning Herald article are accurate.
bloody ripper read on Tom Tate, mayor of the Gold Coast and all-round different sort of bloke to you and i: https://t.co/mfw6smJoeZ— Vince Rugari (@VinceRugari) March 6, 2016
Tom Tate: Bovver boy?
Explaining why Tate wasn’t close to his developer father as a child, Robson tells of a “disagreement” in the mayor’s youth:
At the time, his [Tate’s] father owned a hotel in Manly. Waiting at the pub to see his father, Tate rebuked a "dickhead loudmouth" picking on another patron in the bar. "Then he started to pick on me," he says. "So I nailed him, and got him on the ground ... and then Dad walked in. He thought I was drunk and had started the whole thing. He didn't ask what happened. He just turned and walked out, and I thought, 'Bugger you, why should I explain?' ... and we had no contact for about eight months."
Youthful exuberance? Perhaps, except Tate still appears to enjoy throwing his weight around.
The Gold Coast Bulletin's 5 March 2016 article on local bodybuilder Tom Tate
For instance, Robson asks Tate why he pumps iron:
The mayor looks at me blankly. "It's more like this," he says. "If you've done heavy weights and all that, and people come up to intimidate you, you just smile" – he unleashes a sample grin – "because you're not intimidated. If you bench 130 kilos, what's this 80-kilo guy gunna do to intimidate you?"
Tate enjoys abusing young journalists.
While he trains, I get my first taste of Tate's disarming candour. Local journalists, he muses, tend to be young and too inexperienced to understand life, "So now I just go, 'Gimme the question, here's your answer, f... off!' "
More from the Gold Coast Bulletin's 5 March 2016 article on Gold Coast pub bouncer Tom Tate
Tom Tate: Troll mayor?
Is Tate a bovver boy, like Wilson claims? A bully? Or is he just a troll?
Robson once more:
Last October, when a social media user questioned Tate's involvement with the World Tower project, and asked him to define "corruption", the mayor raged back on Facebook: "... look it up in your Dicktionary ... Also look up idiot while you're at it." In January, during another row over him accepting a free jaunt to Melbourne from a telco later awarded a $150 million council contract, Tate told a journalist to "stop smoking grass".
In his fiery six minute opening address, Mayor Tom Tate’s politeness was further drawn into question when Jim Wilson accused him of allegedly “defrauding” a former business partner, Amanda Duncan-Strelec, by paying for his share in an Albury property development business with allegedly “fraudulent forestry bonds”. And then afterwards, said Wilson, “perjuring” himself about it in court.
According to Wilson, Tate utterly “destroyed” the lady’s family financially and has caused her to still suffer from "deep depression” — which, if true, hardly seems gallant, chivalrous or polite.
You can read Amanda Strelec-Duncan’s eye-opening account of her dealings with Tom Tate HERE.
(Image via tomtatemastermanipulator.weebly.com)
Nothing about this, of course, has appeared in the staunchly pro-Tate local News Corp newspaper, the Gold Coast Bulletin. Instead, the paper has allegedly berated Wilson for having a “vendetta” against his opponent.
Tallebudgera-based Wilson, an Independent running on a “truth, accountability and transparency” ticket, issued the following statement about the Bulletin's alleged bias on Tuesday:
I have been informed by the Editor of the Gold Coast Bulletin today that despite my protestations to the contrary, he sees me as having a vendetta against Tom Tate. I told editor Ken Robertson that I only dressed Tate down on Monday night because he called me and other candidates “fu..kers who speak bu...hit".
(Image screenshot facebook.com/jimwilsonformayor)
Tom Tate: The Bully's boy?
Not only that, but according to Wilson, the Murdoch rag ‒ virtually the only source of news on the election for Gold Coast residents ‒ has been deliberately concealing Wilson’s policies, under the gob-smacking guise of requiring “exclusivity” over them [IA emphasis]:
I was also informed today by Andrew Potts of the Bulletin that I have had no coverage of my policies in the Bulletin because I have not given them exclusivity of my policies that I delivered to them and the subsequent press releases. They don't want me to share with Channel 9 for example….
…. A Complaint to the Press Council is to follow.
Wilson’s policies are, as you would fully expect, published on his website, on Facebook and on Youtube.
Just not in the local paper. Anywhere.
Independent Australia contacted GC Bulletin reporter Andrew Potts several days ago about this alleged requirement for exclusivity, but has not, at time of publication, received any response.
Perhaps this quote from Robson’s enthusiastic story about Tate suggests why The Bulletin has little interest in investigating any allegations about the mayor:
The mayor's friend, Bob Gordon, a former editor of the Gold Coast Bulletin, scoffs at such carping, saying the Coast was an "economic wasteland" before Tate set about building it into a great city, and the biggest liars he knows are greenies: "As an editor ... I went through [Tate's business affairs] with a fine-tooth comb, and there was nothing there ... No sign of corruption at all."
Move along, says the mayor's friend, the former editor of the "Bully". Nothing to see here!
Back home on the Grange
And as for that Grange, Wilson did have something to say about that:
I reminded Mr Robertson that I was asked 3 weeks ago by the Bulletin reporters Paul Weston and Andrew Potts if I wanted to make anything out of Mayor Tate's greed in accepting a $750 bottle of Penfolds Grange from the organiser of a charity gig and I said 'no', as I only wanted coverage for my policies that I had hand delivered to the Bulletin and discussed. I had no interest in bagging Mr Tate, given the adverse feedback I had received about him.
The Gold Coast Bulletin, however, denied they ever had asked Wilson about the Grange — or at least they didn’t "remember" doing so…
(Image screenshot facebook.com/jimwilsonformayor)
So much for fearless, unbiased, investigative journalism. There are many questions foul-mouthed bully-boy Mayor Tom Tate needs to answer, but you won't see them being asked by the Gold Coast Bulletin. You may see them getting asked by Jim Wilson at the mayoral debates, however, much to the Bully's apparent displeasure.
Welcome to politics, Gold Coast style. Where the pollies are polite bullies, the paper is blind and probably bent, and the brown paper bags bring some very fine drops.
Independent Australia streaming Tuesday night's Gold Coast mayoral debate
The Gold Coast Council election will be held next weekend, Saturday 19 March.
But before then, on Tuesday 15 March at 6.30 pm, IA will be live streaming the final Gold Coast mayoral debate to be held at the Nerang Bicentennial Hall.
Watch the GC mayoral debate live online: watchlive.com.au/gcelection
You can also join the debate in real time on Twitter by using the hashtag #GCMayorMeets.
Tweets using this hashtag will also be streamed below the video on that page.
You can follow managing editor Dave Donovan on Twitter @davrosz.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Australia License
Gold Coast Mayor Tom Tate has failed to deliver on a third of his election promises. https://t.co/OxaVLnpV6S #GCVotes— justin harbour (@justinbarbour) March 7, 2016
Independent mayoral candidate Jim Wilson's how to vote card