The closure of SBS World Watch raises concerns about the broadcaster's commitment to cultural diversity at a time when multiculturalism is increasingly under threat, writes Tony Smith.
GIVEN THAT MOST parties with representation in the Australian Parliament are now talking about limiting immigration, multiculturalism needs all the friends it can get.
It could once be assumed that the Special Broadcasting Service (SBS) was among the staunchest allies of an ethnically and culturally diverse society.
Two recent developments in SBS broadcasting are therefore worrying.
First, instead of the former warning that some TV programs made overseas might not reflect SBS values, there is now an announcement that the SBS code does not apply to them at all. This suggests that it is no use complaining about programs which viewers wish to criticise for their content. Management seems to have washed their hands of responsibility for these bulletins.
Earlier, I suggested that the SBS code was a farce when so many programs contained violence. Indeed, most trailers seen on SBS contain physical harm, shootings, explosions and implied threats. The broadcaster does not run advice that the SBS code is potentially breached by any of these programs.
The second change is that, should you turn to SBS 35 World Watch, you find the channel closed. Formerly, I would take in some of the news from Indonesia, Italy, Portugal, Spain, France, Greece, Holland and Poland and bulletins from France 24 in Arabic. I am not fluent in these languages, but often the visuals helped with understanding and the news from Portugal was always accompanied by people signing.
Now that all these bulletins are off the air, part of my interest in the languages is gone. I no longer hear the melodies and rhythms in which the presenters spoke. I can no longer see and hear national differences in reporting. My curiosity about these countries has been reduced.
While SBS radio still broadcasts in community languages, I can seldom understand the bulletins. And while SBS reminds us that these TV news bulletins are available online, the process of accessing them is different. The casual viewer is unlikely to stumble across programs that might arouse curiosity about the countries in which the bulletins originate.
Besides, instead of an Italian speaker, for example, feeling part of a simultaneous public multicultural audience, the need to log on means watching and listening in isolation on a private device.
There are still overseas bulletins from several countries on other SBS channels, but they are all in English. They are clearly produced with English speakers in mind. They do not challenge us to leave our comfort zones and to hear what is being said in other cultures. Certainly, we need Al Jazeera, France 24, PBS, Te Ao and the Turkish and German bulletins, but they come to us in a form designed for English-speaking consumers.
While I doubt that there is anything conspiratorial in these changes, their timing is disturbing. When the One Nation party is clearly anti-immigration and monocultural in its outlook, when the Coalition seems intent on re-absorbing disaffected voters by swinging in the direction of Hansonite policies and when the Labor Government – coincidentally perhaps – has announced cuts to immigration and made visa applications more difficult for seasonal workers and students, multiculturalism is in dire need of advocates.
English language is rampant worldwide and certainly in Australia. For those of us who are not convinced that the USA is qualified to make decisions for the rest of the world and fear that speaking other languages – especially some form of Chinese – is being discouraged for insidious political purposes, making other languages difficult to hear is an alarming development.
When the President of the USA tries to embarrass or ban journalists from press conferences because they ask difficult questions, we should not assume that the news coming from intimidated sources is sound. Never mind complaining.
I would rather risk the possibility that the news bulletins do not meet SBS standards than to do without them. I feel patronised by this unexpected channel closure. How the many Australians whose first language is not English feel, I can only imagine. At a guess, I am afraid that many of them feel abandoned and think that their belonging is being threatened.
I have been surprised that there has been so little comment about the closure. I sent feedback to SBS through their webpage asking for an explanation and wrote to the Minister for Multicultural Affairs in Canberra asking whether the Australian Government had a position on the closing of Channel 35.
I also asked one community group which runs language programs about the impact on its services. I have not heard from this group and have no desire to second-guess its response. I assume that it has noticed the closure but has decided not to comment. I have seen no evidence that any community group supported the closure.
I have not been informed whether the Australian Government has a position, but I received a prompt and courteous reply from SBS Audience Relations, expressing understanding that some people would have difficulty accessing World Watch On Demand and that they might be disappointed by the closure.
They did not say that they had received any other feedback on the matter. They provided links to a number of statements and assistance with accessing the programs online, but I am still unclear why this closure was necessary.
Surely the impetus to move programs to ‘On Demand’ should apply just as much – perhaps more so – to other channels, especially the Movie Channel 32, which possibly runs more repeats than any other channel on SBS or the ABC, and the many individual programs obsessed with wars and violence past, present and fictional.
Hopefully these developments do not represent the beginning of the demise of multicultural Australia.
In keeping with the Liberal National Labor Triad Coven Party Parties Policy of Censorship of the News, the Government has closed the #SBS World Watch News Channel and will no longer broadcast Foreign News Services ! https://t.co/SXZiK6QpFV
— Gregory J O'Flaherty (@schitzoziris) September 18, 2026
Dr Tony Smith is a former political science academic with interests in parliament, elections and ethics.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Australia License
Support independent journalism Subscribe to IA.







