Malcolm Turnbull implementing Tony Abbott's policies at #COP21 says Shorten

By | | comments |

"Australia’s government is saying is we’re not Tony Abbott, but the truth of the matter is we’ve still got Tony Abbot’s policies," says Bill Shorten in Paris. Kyla Mandel and Brendan Montague report for DeSmog UK.

Bill Shorten, the Australian Labor Party leader, attacked Australian climate policy as lacking in ambition ysterday at the Paris climate conference.

Shorten held an impromtu press conference among surprised reporters at the COP21 conference moments after the country's new prime minister Malcolm Turnbull announced his commitment to the second stage of the Kyoto Protocol, as well as plans to raid the foreign aid budget to stump up $1 billion for climate action in the South Pacific.

“Today Malcolm Turnbull has turned up and played it safe,” he said. 

“He’s keeping the right wing of his own party happy. He is really basically, with a slightly different rhetoric, implementing the substance of Tony Abbott’s climate change policies which were notorious for not being serious.”

He added:

“The whole point of gathering is not just to do very little and just commit to the second stage of Kyoto, it’s to move beyond that."

Tony Abbott's low bar

Abbott has long been known to doubt the science of climate change. Naomi Klein went so far as to call him a climate “villain”.

But then this past September Turnbull challenged Abbott for the leadership of the Liberal Party and within half a day, had been voted the new leader. Environmentalists heralded this as an important win against climate denial.

However, Shorten argued yesterday that despite this change in leadership, the country’s policies have remained the same. 

“It’s a pretty low bar this Australian government had to measure up to,” he said.

"The fact of the matter is what Australia’s government is saying is we’re not Tony Abbott but the truth of the matter is we’ve still got Tony Abbot’s policies. What has changed other than the prime minister in terms of Australia’s climate change efforts? Nothing has really changed. Australia is playing it safe … and in the meantime we’re seeing for instance the Canadians who… not only have they changed their prime minister but they’re doubling the amount of money they’re putting into adaptation and climate fund programmes globally, and that’s not the case in Australia.”

When pressed on whether this still marked an improvement given Abbott’s notorious climate inaction, Shorten said:

“Most Australians if they were replacing Tony Abbott would have done more than Tony Abbott has done. Using Tony Abbott as your benchmark on serious climate change policy is not really setting much of a test is it?”

This story was originally published by DeSmogBlog on 30 November 2015 under the title 'Australia ‘Implementing Tony Abbott’s Policies' at COP21 Says Opposition Leader' and has been republished with permission. 

Monthly Donation


Single Donation


Don't parrot the budgie smuggler. Subscribe to Independent Australia.

Recent articles by Kyla Mandel
Even the U.S. Capitol attack is an opportunity for climate deniers

Prominent climate science deniers moved rapidly to spread false and misleading ...  
Pesticide companies marketing themselves as a solution to climate change

'Like a pandemic, climate change is an inevitable threat that we must address ...  
Media perpetuates climate science denial with Ian Plimer article

Geologist and former professor of mining geology, Ian Plimer, has undermined ...  
Join the conversation
comments powered by Disqus

Support IAIndependent Australia

IA is dedicated to providing fearless, independent journalism, free for all, with no barriers. But we need your help. To keep us speaking truth to power, please consider donating to IA today - even a dollar will make a huge difference - or subscribe and receive all the benefits of membership. Keep ‘em honest. Support IA.

Close Subscribe Donate