Notorious climate science denier Marc Morano is heading to Australia to promote his discredited film, 'Climate Hustle', featuring "experts" without climate science expertise. DeSmogBlog's Graham Readfearn reports.
Morano is the communications director at the mistitled Committee for a Constructive Tomorrow (CFACT) — one among a suite of U.S.-based conservative “free market” groups that helped convince President Donald Trump to pull the country out of the international Paris climate agreement.
Climate Hustle, first screened in late 2015 in Paris, claims human-caused climate change is a scare story and that scientists actually disagree about whether humans are causing global warming.
In reality, climate scientists and campaigners say the documentary is a rehash of long-debunked talking points, cherry-picked claims and misrepresentations promoted by a “fossil fuel salesman.”
According to promotional materials, the film will screen in Melbourne on 12 July at the State Library of Victoria, in Brisbane on 15 July at New Farm Cinema and then on 18 July in Sydney at Club Five Dock.
Morano told DeSmog he wants to encourage Australia to withdraw from the United Nations Paris agreement — a step taken by the President Donald Trump, who has packed his administration with staff members who reject the conclusions of the world’s scientific community that greenhouse gases are causing climate change.
Climate scientists who have reviewed the film for DeSmog have described Climate Hustle as “muddled”, “misleading” and “the usual rubbish from the usual suspects”.
Anticipating that Morano and his two colleagues also travelling from the United States will seek media coverage, campaigners said the group should be ignored.
A Greenpeace spokesperson said:
“The last thing we need is another fossil fuel salesman."
Origins of Climate Hustle
The Cornwall Alliance denies any evidence that human-caused climate change is dangerous and promotes “experts” that promote creationism.
Climate Hustle was first shown in public in December 2015 at a farcical “world premiere” in Paris, as United Nations climate talks were ongoing across the city.
Before and after the film was released, Morano gave multiple media interviews on conservative TV networks in the United States.
In May 2016, the film was shown in about 400 U.S. cinemas after CFACT paid a distributor for a one-night-only broadcast of the film.
The film gained more media coverage after Morano secured the enthusiastic endorsement of former Alaska Governor Sarah Palin, prompting a combination of disdain and ridicule.
At the European Parliament in Brussels in October 2016, Climate Hustle was shown by a group of Eurosceptics to a near empty room in the EU Parliament.
Aside from rehashing long-debunked myths about climate science, the movie itself has been described by one filmmaker as “very amateurish” and “not very watchable.”
Who is Marc Morano?
“... manmade global warming is the greatest hoax ever perpetrated on the American people.”
Morano told DeSmogBlog:
We are taking a quick hop to Australia to help export the awesomeness of what is currently happening in the U.S. when it comes to climate policy.
There is no reason we climate sceptics in the U.S. should not be exporting our good fortune of rejecting the UN Paris pact. Climate sceptics in the U.S. have been grinning ear to ear for months now. We have lots to get done in Australia. At the top of the list is helping to spread a global Clexit — climate exit from the UN Paris pact.
According to CFACT’s financial disclosures, Morano earns US$190,000 a year (AU$250,000) for his efforts to convince people that burning fossil fuels is not causing dangerous climate change. CFACT has previously received cash from fossil fuel interests including ExxonMobil and has accepted millions from two secretive linked funds – Donors Trust and Donors Capital Fund – that have become a key funding stream for climate science denial groups.
Eurosceptics Screen 'Climate Hustle' Denial Film to Mostly Empty Room in Brussels Parliamenthttps://t.co/U7AOhL8Yjl— Collin Maessen (@CollinMaessen) November 7, 2016
“Morano is one of the most notorious climate deniers worldwide. Given how certain scientists are worldwide about the links between our man-made emissions and climate change, we are well beyond listening to the likes of a Morano, who wants to do nothing but slow us down on the urgent action we need.”
Marc Morano has no scientific training yet tries to argue with scientists, he is paid by industry groups with a vested interest in fossil fuels yet cries conspiracy.
He is a fossil fuels salesman masquerading as a climate sceptic and should be ignored. The last thing we need is another fossil fuel salesman spreading more lies and climate charlatanism.
Morano was thrown out of the 2016 United Nations climate talks in Morocco for holding an unauthorised protest while standing next to a life-size cutout of Donald Trump. At the time, Morano was with a delegation headed by Myron Ebell, who was part of Donald Trump's team tasked with preparing the Environmental Protection Authority for the new administration.
Usual suspects, usual rubbish
Climate Hustle, running at 78 minutes, is a grab-bag collection of climate denial myths, featuring a well-known cast of contrarian voices, many of which have no actual climate science expertise.
“This is just the usual rubbish from the usual suspects — a re-hash of misleading and downright incorrect arguments that denialists have trotted out for a long time.”
One section of the film attempts to quantify the role of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere and downplay the role of carbon dioxide.
Steffen said the section “misrepresents how the carbon cycle works” by completely ignoring how oceans and land absorb CO2 — a very basic and well-known mechanism in the carbon cycle that’s taught in schools around the world.
“What the film didn't say is that both oxygen and nitrogen, which comprise about 99 per cent of the atmospheric gases, are transparent to UV, visible and heat radiation. They don't play a role in the energy balance at the Earth's surface.”
Whilst there are certainly other potential drivers of changes in the climate we know that over the last century, we have greatly increased the CO2 concentration in the atmosphere and, through detection and attribution analyses, we know that the rising levels of atmospheric CO2 and other greenhouse gases have driven the rise in global temperature.
Changes in other potential drivers, like solar activity, simply can't explain the 1C rise in global temperature we have observed.
Attacking the consensus
Large parts of the film try to convince the audience that scientists disagree about the causes of climate change.
Morano told DeSmog:
“Our goal with our trip is to provide Australians with a break from the manufactured ‘consensus’ and entertain by showing audiences how silly man-made climate change claims have become.”
One section quotes economist Professor Richard Tol attacking a study that found that 97 per cent of climate scientists agree humans are causing global warming.
The film doesn’t say that Tol himself has also said:
“There is no doubt in my mind that the literature on climate change overwhelmingly supports the hypothesis that climate change is caused by humans. I have very little reason to doubt that the consensus is indeed correct.”
Cook told DeSmog that attempts to cast doubt on the scientific consensus that humans are causing climate change had been a key strategy for opponents to greenhouse gas reductions.
This dates back to the late 1990s when political strategists conducted market research to find that attacking the consensus was one of the most effective ways to reduce public support for climate policy. The Climate Hustle film closely follows this playbook, devoting a significant chunk of its film casting doubt on the consensus.
The film attacks our 2013 paper that found 97% consensus among peer-reviewed climate papers stating a position on human-caused global warming. It also attacks Peter Doran’s 2009 paper that found 97% consensus among actively publishing climate scientists. However, these two papers are only two among a number of independent studies each finding an overwhelming scientific consensus on climate change.
In 2016, we teamed up with co-authors of seven key consensus studies to publish a survey-of-surveys. Among papers that examined expert agreement among publishing climate scientists, we found 90 to 100% agreement on human-caused global warming with a number of studies converging on 97%.
“CFACT has a lot of fans and followers in Australia who have long wanted us to make a trip. We were beckoned to come and are excited to premiere our film Climate Hustle.”
According to one climate science denial blog, groups helping to organise the CFACT trip are the Galileo Movement (once managed by current One Nation Senator Malcolm Roberts), the Australian Environment Foundation, the Australian Taxpayers Alliance and the Australian Institute for Progress.
Support reality. Subscribe to IA for just $5.